She Is Not Invisible ~ Marcus Sedgwick

IMG_0669One of my January ‘not quite resolutions but outcomes I’d like to achieve during the next twelve months’ was to read more fiction aimed at children and young adults.  As you probably already know, I spent almost twenty years lecturing in this area, having spent the previous twenty running various school libraries, so perhaps it isn’t all that surprising that for a time I veered away from the category.  However, sitting in the basement at Heywood Hill (that shop has so much to answer for) and pouring over their wonderful selection of children’s literature I realised how much I was missing being up to date, especially in relation to picture books and YA material.  Inevitably, during my ‘sabbatical’ a whole new raft of writers has come onto the scene and I shall need to do some research before I dip into their work, so initially I’ve gone for the more recent publications by authors whose work I already know and love, including Marcus Sedgwick’s fascinating novel, She Is Not Invisible.

One of the most remarkable features of Sedgwick’s novel is the fact that he writes it almost completely without reference to what anything in the setting looks like.  This comes about because the first person protagonist, sixteen year old Laureth, is blind and as a consequence can’t tell us anything of the visual impact of the world around her.  What description we do get of the journey that she and her very much younger brother undertake comes from Benjamin’s point of view and as he doesn’t always understand what he is seeing this can be as disorientating for us as it is for Laureth, indeed, probably more so as she is used to interpreting her surroundings through limited and possibly distorted information.  It’s an interesting take on the concept of the unreliable narrative and a lesson in what that can mean when a literary feature steps out of the pages of fiction and into the real world.

Sedgwick takes this theme of interpretation of the world around us further in the story he unfolds.  Laureth is worried because she cannot contact her father, the author, Jack Peak.  After a successful early career writing humorous fiction, Jack has become obsessed with writing a novel to do with coincidences, or ‘co-inky-dinks’ as Benjamin calls them.  But what is a coincidence?  Is it something remarkable or is it a phenomenon easily explained when you actually look at the science and mathematics behind the likelihood of the event occurring?  Well, whatever else it is, it is the impetus that has driven Jack Peak’s life over the past number of years and that has also driven a wedge between him and his wife, so when he goes missing Laureth’s greatest fear is that this is the beginning of the end for her parents’ marriage.  Until, that is, she receives a mysterious communication from someone in New York who offers proof that he has found her father’s precious writer’s notebook and claims the reward advertised therein.  With only Benjamin (and Stan, but you’ll have to discover him for yourselves) as a guide, Laureth sets out to discover if this is indeed the truth.

As this is most definitely a thriller that is as far as I’m going in respect of the plot but some of the themes are worth considering further and again I ask, what is a coincidence?  Mathematicians will frequently explain away specific apparent coincidences by showing us that when the numbers are crunched the chances of that coincidence occurring are actually quite high. Any teacher knows that in your average class of thirty children there will be two who were born on the same day.  I don’t think I’ve ever taught a group where that wasn’t the case.  But what about the coincidence that happened to me on Christmas Day?  During the afternoon my god-daughter and I were discussing a play we’d been to see and completely out of the blue she drew an analogy between it and Churchill allowing the bombing of Coventry to go ahead during the Second World War so that the Germans wouldn’t know that we had broken their codes.  Then, later that evening, in the middle of a crime novel set in Canada, what did I come across but exactly the same reference.  What are the mathematical odds against that?

Coincidences have fascinated many of the world’s greatest thinkers.  Both Jung and Einstein wrote about them.  Einstein claimed that coincidence is God’s way of remaining anonymous.  That sounds really profound, but I’m not sure what it means.  Jung, on the other hand, made what seems to me to be a physics related statement when he claimed that;

the connections that occurred during a coincidence were not due to cause and effect, but … were acausal, which means that one thing had not caused the other thing to happen. Instead of causality therefore, he explained that things could be connected by their meaning; so the link between seeing a picture of a salmon just as you’re talking to a man called Salmon is that they share the same meaning.

This sounds to me to be describing a field relationship as opposed to the more linear relationship by means of which we tend to understand our lives, a concept that Einstein, as a physicist should have appreciated.  All of this, and a great deal more is explored in Sedgwick’s text but the author couches it in a manner that is guaranteed to catch the interest of any teenager who picks the novel up.

The question that Jack Peak has to answer is both more and less profound than those tackled by Einstein and Jung.  He has to decide whether or not he is going to let his obsession shatter his family life.  To find out which way he jumps and whether that jump is literal or figurative you will need to read the book.  Don’t be put off by the fact that it is aimed at a Young Adult audience. Like so many books with a YA designation this novel has much to say to an adult readership as well.


13 thoughts on “She Is Not Invisible ~ Marcus Sedgwick

  1. Annabel (gaskella) March 13, 2014 / 2:33 pm

    Sedgwick is my favourite YA author without a doubt, his work is so varied. This is on my pile to read, so I shall really enjoy it when I get to it I know. Lovely review.


    • Alex March 14, 2014 / 12:03 pm

      I have his first novel for adults on my tbr pile, Annabel, and can’t wait to read it.


  2. litlove March 13, 2014 / 2:53 pm

    What a fascinating premise – no physical orientation because the main protagonist is blind. It does make me recall (inaccurately, no doubt) that quote from Madeleine L’Engle about writing things for children when the ideas behind them were too difficult for adults. I’ve never read Marcus Sedgwick, but if you and Annabel like him, I should really try and squeeze him in!


    • Alex March 14, 2014 / 12:06 pm

      I don’t know if it was L’Engle, Litlove, but whoever it was they spoke the truth. YA and children’s books often deal head-on with topics adults would run a mile from.


  3. Stefanie March 13, 2014 / 4:33 pm

    What an interesting sounding book! And what a start to catching up in the field. The idea of a YA book about coincidence is fascinating. I would have loved such a book and since there weren’t any like this when I was a kid it is probably why I launched out into reading science fiction.


    • Alex March 14, 2014 / 12:07 pm

      Believe me, Stefanie, some of the best and most innovative writing is happening in the YA/Children’s books today. Those of us who grew up in the 50s, 60s and 70s don’t know what we’re missing.


    • Alex March 14, 2014 / 12:13 pm

      Even after reading this I still can’t make up my mind as to where I stand on coincidences, Margaret, but what I do like are books that make me think and that is certainly what this one does.


  4. Harriet Devine March 14, 2014 / 9:15 am

    Good lord, this sounds amazing. I’m rarely attracted to YA but clearly I’m missing something as you’ve made me long to read this. Great review!


    • Alex March 14, 2014 / 12:14 pm

      He has his first adult novel, ‘A Love Like Blood’ coming out at the end of the month, Harriet. You might like to try that first.


  5. BookerTalk March 15, 2014 / 5:19 pm

    YA isn’t something I’ve experienced much. I did read a few when I started a children’s lit course (had to put that on hold for a while) and as you said, there’s been a huge change in approach in literature for younger people since I were a lass. I was amazed at how the subject matter seems to be more challenging, more willing to engage in ‘taboos’.


    • Alex March 16, 2014 / 2:52 pm

      Have you read Melvin Burgess’s novel ‘Junk’, Karen? Now there’s a book that nearly caused riots when it was first published and is still controversial today.


      • BookerTalk March 16, 2014 / 6:31 pm

        I have indeed – I thought it was incredibly well done. But of course it won’t please people who think children don’t get into such problems


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s