The Winter Foundlings ~ Kate Rhodes

the-winter-foundlingsI was lucky enough to stumble across Kate Rhodes’ work just after the first Alice Quentin novel, Crossbones Yard, was published.  Two things struck me immediately about that book, the quality of Rhodes writing and her knowledge of London.  Rhodes, who is a Londoner by birth, is also a published poet and both these factors are clearly influential in her series of crime novels about a psychologist who reluctantly finds herself working with the police to apprehend criminals who are also seriously disturbed individuals.

The Winter Foundlings is no exception to the established pattern.  Alice has taken a six month research placement at Northwood, a high security hospital where she is hoping that she will have time to recover from her last assignment with the Metropolitan Police Force.  However, a series of child abductions which has so far resulted in three murders, proves to have links to one of the Northwood inmates, Louis Kinsella, and although it is impossible that he can have been physically involved it is clear that in someway he is inspiring the current kidnappings.  Reluctantly, Alice agrees to try and interview him in order to seek information that might lead to the arrest of whoever is responsible and the rescue of the latest victim, Ella.

Northwood proves to be a place where many of the employees are damaged individuals themselves, which forces both Alice and the reader to ask questions about the nature of those who choose to work in such an environment and the harm that such employment can do to people who take it up.  It also, of course, provides Rhodes with a plethora of suspects.  It very soon becomes apparent that there is a connection between the crimes and the Foundling Museum which commemorates the Hospital established by Thomas Coram in 1739 where mothers who could no longer care for their children could leave them to be raised.  Kinsella, who at the time of his arrest was headmaster of a school, had always taken a particular interest in children from troubled backgrounds and the theory that emerges is that he has influenced at least one of these damaged minds to the extent that in adulthood they have followed him into a life of crime.  But which one?  It was only twenty pages from the end when I felt confident that I could predict the villain of the piece and even then the way in which the final scenes would play out was unclear.

One of the structural features of this novel is a narrative split between the main aspects of the story as they feature Alice and the events as they are seen from the point-of-view of ten year old Ella, the most recent victim.  Normally, I find this method of story-telling very difficult to deal with.  It often seems to have been adopted only as an excuse for introducing gratuitous violence and I tend to agree with the Ancient Greek playwrights that such actions are better kept off stage and reported to the audience via a convenient messenger.  Here, however, the second narrative is a vital part of both the story and the psychological phenomenon that Rhodes is exploring.  Ella may be a child, but she is mentally very mature for her age and capable of thinking clearly and understanding the situation she is in.  Her captor, on the other hand, though physically adult, is still, in many respects, the damaged youngster who fell under the influence of Kinsella before he was caught and committed.  What I found interesting was that while such individuals might most commonly be thought of as still being a child, when you observe them in the company of an astute child like Ella you can see that that isn’t an accurate description at all.  The damage that has been done to them may have in some way retarded their emotional and psychological development but they are nothing like a child and I wonder how much more damage society inflicts by not realising the difference.  Perhaps this is something of which professionals who work in places like Northwood are well aware, but this book certainly made me stop and think about my own perceptions.

Kate Rhodes is fast becoming one of my favourite crime writers and certainly one I can recommend to you if you haven’t already encountered her work.  I’m very grateful to Mulholland Books for sending me a copy of this latest novel for review.


8 thoughts on “The Winter Foundlings ~ Kate Rhodes

  1. This sounds like a good mystery series. Our library sadly doesn’t have any of her books yet. I have bookmarked the first in the series on Amazon for when I do my next purchases. Thanks for the review, Alex. Some of the reviews on Amazon discussed the main character, Alice and her childhood that has damaged her. Do you find that having such a damaged main protagonist adds or detracts from the reliability of the investigation? I’m curious how you found this character, as you have read more in the series.


    1. Alice isn’t the damaged character that say, Tony Hill, is and it doesn’t really affect the stories. Her brother, Will, has suffered far more, but he is increasingly peripheral. Do read them in order. I think this is a series where that makes a difference.


  2. Sounds great — but is there no end to the books I am forced to seek out after reading your reviews? Really must look out for this series. Thanks.


    1. I think you’ll enjoy them, Harriet. There is nothing fancy about the writing but Rhodes’ background as a poet shines through them all. As this is only number three, if you can find the time I would go back to ‘Crossbones Yard’ and start at the beginning.

      As to recommending books…… there is a review of a novel going up at the beginning of next week that neither you nor I would never normally have given a second thought to. Fortunately, I heard a review of it on the radio from two people whose opinions I value and consequently had one of my reads of the year. You will simply have to get a copy.


  3. Im having the same feeling as Harriet, you are doing serious damage to my wish list. I wouldn’t usually go for something with this kind of subject matter but it sounds like it is extremely well written .


    1. It is, Karen, although if you can find the time then I would suggest that you start at the beginning of the series so that you get the full picture of Alice’s background.


  4. I remember you mentioning this author before and feeling most curious about the work. I love crime fiction that involves psychotherapists/psychologists and will clearly have to read this one!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s