The Dark Circle ~ Linda Grant

Linda Grant’s most recent novel is set primarily in the early 1950s. Twins, Lenny and Miriam Lynskey, are set to conquer the world.  The only cloud on their horizon is Lenny’s impending spell of National Service, but that is a minor problem because Uncle Manny knows someone who can fix it.  What Uncle Manny can’t fix, however, is the result of the chest x-ray that Lenny has as part of his medical.  He has tuberculosis: a disease which hovered over the lives of everyone in that period, regardless of age, class or ethnicity.  Lenny and Miriam, who for all of their eighteen years have shared not only a room but also a bed, are packed off to the Gwendo, a sanatorium deep in what is, to them, an alien environment – the countryside.

The Gwendo started life as a private enterprise, but the introduction of the National Health Service has changed all that, much to the distress of the most of the staff working there, who have never come across anything quite like these East End Jewish teenagers.

Mrs Carver, Matron you must call her, did not have to check her files to know that they were coming under the National Health scheme and wouldn’t pay a penny out of their own pockets, they could hang around as long as they liked and it wouldn’t cost them a farthing. And they would stay, she felt sure of that. They would burrow into the system like parasites and milk it for everything they could get. Clean sheets, wholesome food, all the leisure time in the world. It was a skiver’s paradise, a sanatorium which had been built for a better class of persons, and there was nothing at all that she could do to protect the admirable Lady Anne from the sight of cheap loud vulgar people.

For many of the inmates, however, Lenny and Miriam provide a much need diversion, because the presiding ethos, as laid down by Doctor Limb and the formidable Mrs Carver, dictates that in order to be a patient one has to learn to be patient – a word that isn’t in the twins vocabulary. Whatever Matron may think, they have no intention of staying in the Gwendo a moment longer than they can help and while they are there they are going to make their presence felt.

But if the lives of the long term residents, including a group of service men who have become infected during the war, a set known as the Mothers’ Union and most pitifully the cruelly treated and isolated children, are changed by the Twins’ presence, Lenny and Miriam are transformed too.  Two fellow inmates are primarily responsible for this: first there is Valerie Lewis, a middle class Oxbridge graduate with whom Miriam shares treatment. Forced to spend days and weeks doing nothing but lie in bed on an outside balcony, regardless of weather, the two women forge an unlikely, but ultimately mutually beneficial, friendship.  Miriam teaches Valerie about make-up, while Valerie introduces her and through her, Lenny, to the world of literature.

And then into their lives comes Arthur Persky a name to shatter glass.  Arthur is an American sailor turfed off his ship when he is discovered to be ill and sent to the Gwendo until such time as he is deemed fit enough to return to the States.  He blows through the Sanatorium like a hurricane, bringing with him the latest rock and roll music and an approach to sexual morality which takes the inmates by storm.  Miriam is completely won over and can see only a future spent in Stateside luxury.

But without effective treatment there will be no future for any of them and the much hailed streptomycin is in pitifully short supply.

‘Because we fought a war and we’re broke, that’s why, and now we’re practically bankrupt. We have to buy it from America. We haven’t got the exchange currencies. I’ve heard that penicillin and streptomycin are kept in the military wards under armed guard while the kiddies are dying off like flies of infections.’

Six precious doses are made available and the question of distribution eventually leads to the Gwendo’s downfall.

I first read The Dark Circle when it was short listed for the Bailey’s Women’s Prize earlier this year and enjoyed it so much that I recommended it to one of my book groups.  Apart from anything else we are all of an age to have some memories of this period and a number of us had relatives who had succumbed to TB before antibiotics were available.  In fact reception was mixed.  About half the group had been as impressed as I was, others not so and one member positively disliked it. None, however, had read it in quite the way I had.  I read this novel as very much an allegory reflecting the changes that came about in Britain in the 50s, with the Gwendo as a microcosmic world indicative of the societal shake up that followed the war years and the 1944 Labour Government’s reforms. When Persky blows in halfway through the twins’ treatment for me this is symbolic of the way in which the strength of American influence began to predominate in the middle part of that decade.  This then makes sense of the latter part of the novel which reflects from present day affluence on a time when genuinely we were all in it together only then to add, for a while we were, at any rate. Grant clearly does not feel that we are all in together any longer:

For always in the heat, the shimmer of the sun on the surface of the pool, the cicadas in the trees, the smell of suntan oil, the rustling of the maid in the dimness of the kitchen preparing lunch, as if seen from the corner of the eye, a deserted half-ruined building in Kent, a remnant of an old disease, now undergoing a revival. Stealthy, lying low, waiting for a point of weakness in the human race, then lodging in the lungs of humanity to make its sluggish progress through the body, the magnificent shape of our temporary wholeness, until we die and other species take us on.


14 thoughts on “The Dark Circle ~ Linda Grant

    • Café Society October 8, 2017 / 8:42 am

      I think you would enjoy this, Harriet. The story itself is good enough to make it a satisfying read but for me it is about the hopes that we had after the last World War and the questions we have to ask in relation to how far those hopes have been fulfilled. There is also a reference to Muffin the Mule who, as a small child I absolutely adored.


  1. Helen October 8, 2017 / 8:16 pm

    This sounds interesting. I have read one of Linda Grant’s other books, We Had It So Good, and remember enjoying it, so I’ll have to think about reading this one too. It sounds like the sort of book that can be read on more than one level.


    • Café Society October 8, 2017 / 8:26 pm

      It is Helen. It is also a book which can be read either as a piece of contemporary writing or as an historical novel, very much depending on your age. I just remember some of the things she is writing about as I was born the year before the story begins.


  2. Grab the Lapels October 9, 2017 / 12:34 am

    This book sounds strangely like a twist on One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest.


    • Café Society October 10, 2017 / 7:53 pm

      I can see why you might think that but the tone and the intent is very different indeed.


  3. JacquiWine October 9, 2017 / 6:17 am

    It does sound like a good one for book groups – an interesting insight into part of our social history.


    • Café Society October 9, 2017 / 7:37 am

      I was surprised how split we were over this one Jacqui. But we nearly always have a better discussion when we don’t all agree.


  4. cleopatralovesbooks October 9, 2017 / 7:54 pm

    This sounds fascinating and interesting how you read it so differently to the rest of your group.


    • Café Society October 9, 2017 / 7:57 pm

      It rang a lot of personal bells for me so I think it was inevitable that I should see it as more than a story just about the characters involved.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. buriedinprint October 12, 2017 / 9:52 pm

    I read one of her others, shortlisted for the award when it was the Orange Prize, and found it quite challenging. In a good way. Though I can imagine it would have divided readers as wel. This one definitely sounds like a worthwhile read, and I’ll be sure to keep my pencil sharpened and peer for the other layers you’ve observed therein.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Café Society October 13, 2017 / 8:39 am

      The more I have thought about this the more I think it really works best when you are aware of the allegorical level. If you miss that then I think you are going to question the accuracy of some of what she writes about, which in this instance isn’t, I think, as important.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Kat October 17, 2017 / 2:43 am

    I loved The Magic Mountain but oddly have never read another TB novel, and I love your interpretation. Have never read Linda Grant: sometimes it’s hard to know which award winners and finalists to read, and yours is the first review that has inspired me to check her out, so thank you.


    • Café Society October 17, 2017 / 1:49 pm

      This is the first of Linda Grant’s novels that I have read as well, but she comes very highly recommended by a reader I really respect so that combined with my enjoyment of this will certainly mean I shall be on the lookout for her next work and will pick up any back catalogue I come across.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s