The Lying Kind ~Alison James

IMG_0093Six year old Lola Jade Harper has been missing for seven months after disappearing from her mother’s home in Eastwell, Surrey.  A child likely to be at the heart of a bitter custody battle, she appears to have been abducted to order and inevitably her father, Gavin, is a major suspect.  Now Gavin has also disappeared and given that there have been reported sightings of Lola Jade on the continent, the National Crime Agency, once better known as Interpol, has been tasked to assist in finding him.  DI Rachel Prince and her Sergeant, Mark Brickall, are handed the file and told to liaise with the Surrey force in an attempt to discover whether the little girl has been taken abroad to keep her from her mother.

However, Michelle Harper may not be all that she seems.  While most of the social network comments are supportive of her, there are other indications that she is seriously unstable and very early in her involvement with the case Rachel finds herself questioning just how sincere Lola Jade’s mother is wanting to find the child. Making sure that her husband takes the blame appears to be much more important. When Gavin is eventually tracked down and it becomes apparent that his daughter isn’t with him attention turns back to the UK and Michelle Harper’s movements come under closer scrutiny.  Why has she moved out of the family home to live with her sister and what is happening to the money that has been collected on a just giving site to help with the search?

The Missing Child raises a number of interesting questions about the dynamics of family life.  If a marriage starts to go wrong how do you deal with the growing awareness that you have made a mistake?  Rachel herself has a failed relationship behind her: one from which she has withdrawn without allowing either herself or her husband any form of closure.  What happens when husband and wife have different views not only about having children but also as to how any children should be brought up?  How much can one sibling ask of another and what are the consequences when sibling bonds are broken?  And, most pertinently, what are the consequences when love for a child is subverted by love of oneself.  Alison James successfully manages to integrate each of these different strands into both the central plot and the background material she provides about her main characters in this her first novel.  At the end of the book the reader is left not only with a satisfactory storyline but also with sufficient detail about Rachel, her Sergeant and their personal and professional histories to feel that they are real people with real lives.

This is an accomplished first novel, well plotted, with convincingly drawn characters and also stylishly written.  It isn’t that often that the first in a series is strong enough to make me automatically put a writer on my go-to list of authors but I shall definitely be on the look out for Alison James’ next novel.  I think she may be a writer to watch.

With thanks to NetGalley for making this available for review.

6 thoughts on “The Lying Kind ~Alison James

  1. helen February 8, 2018 / 10:27 am

    Good review! The questions that the book raises sound really interesting. I tend to shy away from books about missing or murdered children, I have got squeamish about these, but this might be worth getting over myself for.


    • Café Society February 8, 2018 / 10:41 am

      This is a very interesting take on what can be a throughly nasty subject, Helen and I really do think she is a writer to watch. Note that I’ve had to change the title. The publishers emailed me on the day of publication to say that there had been a change. Reviews must have gone out all over the place under the old title. You would have thought they would have had the savvy to tell people sooner.


      • helen February 9, 2018 / 9:23 am

        Not the best organisation, but these things happen and I think the new title is much better.


  2. BookerTalk February 9, 2018 / 6:48 pm

    Impressive for a first novel as you say. There are many novels around that are based on missing children and keep you wondering who is telling the truth but this one seems to be a cut above the norm


    • Café Society February 11, 2018 / 9:19 am

      For various reasons I read it twice, Karen and it held up as well on a second reading as it did on a first. Not something that you can often say about any novel. It’s just a pity that the publishers have played fast and loose with the title. They changed it at the last minute and a lot of reviews will have gone out under the original title which was ‘The Missing Child’.


      • BookerTalk February 14, 2018 / 3:44 pm

        What a strange decision given all the resources already devoted to the marketing- why did they make the switch at such a late stage? Was it a title already used by another author maybe.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s