The Film of the Book ~ Empire of the Sun

IMG_0001Well, it had to happen one day, I suppose.  This year we actually found a film we enjoyed as much as we did the book.  Sorry, I’ve sort of begun in the middle there. One of the book groups to which I belong has a special meeting every year on the second Sunday in September.  Instead of our usual evening gathering we get together for the whole day to discuss a novel in the morning, catch up on our Summer break over lunch and then see the film of the book in the afternoon. The day usually ends with us vilifying whatever film we’ve just seen over afternoon tea. Over the years (sixteen now) we’ve become dab hands at vilifying.  This year our chosen novel was JG Ballard’s 1985 Booker shortlisted Empire of the Sun, which was filmed by Steven Spielberg two years later with screen play by Tom Stoppard.  The latter fact is perhaps a main reason why we all enjoyed the screen version far more than has ever before been the case.

The novel, as I’m sure you all know, is a semi autobiographical account of Ballard’s own childhood experience of being interned by the Japanese after the fall of Shanghai, where he lived with his family in the privileged International Settlement.  Probably the greatest difference in the fictionalised version is that Ballard’s Jim is separated from his parents and has to find a way of surviving on his own, whereas Ballard himself was not separated from the rest of his family, including a three year old sister who doesn’t feature at all in the book.

The aspects of the novel that I found most interesting were emphasised by this change.  What his solitary internment means is that while Jim has to find a way to survive on his own he can also concentrate fully on his own survival.  My father was a Japanese POW, ‘fortunately’ in what is now North Korea rather than on the Burma railways, and he always said that the people for whom he felt most sorry were two brothers who were in the camp together, because they had to worry about each other’s survival as well as their own; no one had the energy to worry about two people.  The internees fears of what would occur at the end of the war, when they were forced to leave the camp was also familiar.  Everyone expected their captors to turn on them and contingency plans were made in case that happened. Likewise, Ballard’s Jim recognises that the forced march that the internees are subjected to after the fall of the atomic bombs is going to end with a bullet and feigns an early death to escape this fate.

While the film is excellent and the performance that a young Christian Bale gives as Jim, quite exceptional, it isn’t exactly the film of the book. Inevitably, the texture is much thinner, especially in the earlier part of the adaptation when Jim is making his way to the camp.  Even a lengthy two and a half hours isn’t time enough to include all the set backs that the eleven year old encounters. And the ending is considerably more ‘happy families’ than Ballard’s original, although I did think that the way in which his father fails to recognise Jim on first pass there was a hint of the estrangement that was to exist between the real Ballard and his father for the rest of their lives.  But, it works as a film in its own right and it is true to the author’s intentions. In fact, the only criticism that anyone offered was that at the very end all the children who were waiting to be reunited with their parents looked far too robust and healthy to be believable as having been internees for over two years but, as I pointed out, starving a whole class-worth of seven year olds just for artistic effect probably wasn’t a goer, however realistic Spielberg might have wanted to be.

I saw the film when it was first released back in 1987 but hadn’t caught up with it since and I was surprised at how much I remembered, especially of Jim’s fascination with aircraft and the ‘relationship’ he forged with the young Japanese Kamikaze pilot. Its quality clearly imposed itself on me way back then and yesterday did nothing to change my original opinion. However, this morning, perversely, I find myself slightly miffed that I can no longer claim that we have never yet seen a film that did justice to the novel because Empire of the Sun definitely bucks the trend.

19 thoughts on “The Film of the Book ~ Empire of the Sun

  1. BookerTalk September 10, 2018 / 4:35 pm

    Can you imagine the fuss if those child actors had been told to lose weight? There is only so far a director can go to make the film authentic. I’ve not seen Dunkirk but there was a large promo photo of it in the Sunday Times which made me cross. Every solider in the boat was clean even though they had gone through hell on the beach. So I decided there and then I didn’t want to see the film…


    • Café Society September 11, 2018 / 8:08 am

      I didn’t see that either. You would have thought they could do something with cgi even if they didn’t want to costume and makeup for verisimilitude.


      • BookerTalk September 12, 2018 / 7:47 pm

        Absolutely – there was no excuse for it.


  2. Liz September 10, 2018 / 5:55 pm

    Phew – finally a film as good as the book. What a rarity! It’s ages since I read or saw either, so must have another look at them. And I love the idea of a day-long book/film/tea-fest – brilliant!


    • Café Society September 11, 2018 / 8:10 am

      We have a great time, Liz. Even if the film is lousey (don’t see The Shipping News or Oscar and Lucinda) pulling it apart is wonderful fun.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Liz September 11, 2018 / 5:17 pm

        I can imagine! 🙂


  3. FictionFan September 10, 2018 / 11:29 pm

    Just occasionally a film works as well as the book, which is a good thing, but does destroy the pleasure of ripping it to shreds! Haha – I reckon they should have starved the kids! I always think that in Dickens adaptations now too – the child always tends to look well on the way to being a 6′ 4″ athlete rather than a starving waif. Are they not willing to suffer for their art?? 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    • Café Society September 11, 2018 / 8:11 am

      Some adult actors have done, of course, but I suppose Spielberg wanted to be able to get distribution.

      Liked by 1 person

      • FictionFan September 11, 2018 / 4:04 pm

        Haha! “No children were harmed during the making of this film…”


  4. Margaret September 11, 2018 / 6:15 am

    Films as enjoyable as books are rare indeed – and Empire of the Sun is a good example! And the book is one I’ve kept for years meaning to re-read it sometime. I don’t suppose I will but I’ve got it down from the shelf this morning after reading your post and am very tempted – if only there weren’t so many other books I want to read …


    • Café Society September 11, 2018 / 8:12 am

      I wouldn’t have reread it had we not chosen it for this year’s meeting, Margaret, but I’m really glad I did. I had forgotten just what a good writer Ballard is.


  5. smithereens September 11, 2018 / 8:47 am

    I watched the movie in the 1990s, but now I think I want to check out the book!


    • Café Society September 11, 2018 / 10:27 am

      Be prepared for the fact that much of Jim’s journey to and from the camp is truncated in the film. But Ballard’s writing is so good that it really doesn’t matter.


  6. Jeanne September 11, 2018 / 9:51 pm

    I remember loving that film; we still have a copy of it on DVD. The film I’ve seen that was better than the book is Postcards from the Edge, by Carrie Fisher. It wasn’t a very good book, but it was an enjoyable film.


    • Café Society September 13, 2018 / 11:57 am

      I don’t know that in either format, Jeanne. I shall have to get hold of a copy.


  7. Kat September 12, 2018 / 9:05 pm

    I told my husband about your book club, and we are both very impressed that you read the book and see the film. Somehow your book clubs are much better than any we’ve had here. I also told him about your themed Summer School.

    Anyway, I love the film, but must confess I’ve never read anything by Ballard. I shall have to look for this.


    • Café Society September 13, 2018 / 11:58 am

      This is very different from anything else he wrote, Kat and I think is probably the only one you would enjoy. As for the book groups, they both began because I couldn’t find the sort of groups that I wanted and so I just upped and started them myself.


  8. mlegan September 21, 2018 / 12:39 pm

    I agree about Empire of the Sun. I’m usually ok if I see a movie, then read the book, but the other way around is rarely successful.


    • Café Society September 21, 2018 / 12:44 pm

      That happened with me with The Colour Purple. I loved the film and couldn’t wait to see it again, but before I got the chance I read the book- the film was never quite so good again.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s