Bellman and Black ~ Diane Setterfield

At a time when everyone else in the blogging world seems to be reading Diane Setterfield’s latest novel, Once Upon A River, I found myself picking up her previous offering, Bellman and Black, it being this month’s choice for one of my Book Groups. I didn’t particularly enjoy Setterfield’s first novel, The Thirteenth Tale, even though it was such a commercial success, and the fact that it was promoted on the cover as a ghost story didn’t do anything to attract me to this second volume – I haven’t read ghost stories since I was fourteen.  But that’s the whole point of a Book Group, isn’t it?  Or at least it is of the two to which I belong.  We read books we would otherwise never have picked up because we trust the instincts of the other group members.  I find it very hard to believe, but this particular group is now in its seventeenth year and during that time I have discovered several authors whose books I would never normally have picked up but who now feature regularly on my reading lists.  So, remembering that the person who had chosen this also introduced me to David Mitchell and Kamila Shamsie, I dived in.

When William Bellman is ten, cheered on by his cousin Charles and friends Fred and Luke, he takes up his catapult, pulls off a remarkable shot and kills a rook.  This is the novel’s opening scene and the reader is encouraged to believe that this incident will colour everything that happens to William from that day on.  Although a grandson of the local Mill owner, it is not William who is in line to take up the business but his cousin, Charles. However, Charles has no interest in the business, indeed no interest in living in England.  His love of painting takes him off to Italy and it is William who joins Paul, his uncle, in the family concern and whose fresh eye and keen brain soon transforms the Mill and all the associated trades.  When his grandfather dies and Paul takes over there is nothing left to stand in the way of William one day succeeding his uncle and not only running, but substantially expanding and innovating the Mill himself. Happily married and with four small children everything seems to be going William’s way until an unnamed epidemic (we speculated either typhoid or diphtheria) hits the village and his wife and three youngest children die while Dora, his eldest, is left both disabled and disfigured.

At each of the funerals he is called upon to attend William is drawn to a shadowy figure in black, someone he feels he should know but just can’t quite pin down in his memory. Memory is something that William avoids, even though Dora tries to recall the family life that they had once known.  William is all to do with thought and as the book reminds us,

[there] is a story much older than this one in which two ravens – which are nothing but large rooks – were companions and advisors to the great God of the north. One bird was called Huginn, which in that place and time meant Thought, and the other Muninn, which meant Memory.

In giving himself over entirely to thought and neglecting to remember his family and all those who were important to him, William cuts himself off from the people who love him and who might have saved him as he becomes more and more obsessed with meeting what he sees as an obligation to the black-coated, shadowy figure from the graveyard.  And yet, ironically, it is memory which is at the root of his next great business success as he goes on to found the magnificent London emporium, Bellman & Black, where everything you need to commemorate your recently departed loved one can be found under one roof.  It was the description of the building and the fitting out of this store (one bound to bring almost unlimited success at the height of Victorian mourning traditions) that I enjoyed  most.  Bought up in trade and with a love of ordering and organising, I was fascinated by the minutiae of how William builds this new business from quite literally the ground upwards.  But, although his name is over the door and on all the carriages and letterheads, the mysterious Black is never seen and gradually his absence begins to build in importance in William’s mind and brings about the novel’s conclusion.

We had a really good discussion about this book, mainly because although we had all found it eminently readable, we none of us thought that it quite held together. Our main complaint was that Setterfield had started too many ideas and not really developed any of them sufficiently. Too often we felt we were having to search for an explanation as to how a particular incident fitted into the overall scheme of things and as a result the ideas, if not the narrative itself, seemed disjointed and not fully developed.  Our estimation of the character of William, however, differed. While some found his obsession with his work disturbing and difficult to understand, others felt it chimed with the experience of trying to build a career in a challenging climate. Ulitimately, of course, William fails because to be obsessed with death in life is to deny living, until all that is left is death itself, those things which make living worthwhile having never been enjoyed.  The book begins and ends with William’s death.  Whether or not he can be said to have lived in the interim is for the individual reader to decide.

13 thoughts on “Bellman and Black ~ Diane Setterfield

  1. kaggsysbookishramblings February 21, 2019 / 4:00 pm

    Intriguing responses. I enjoyed The Thirteenth Tale a lot, but I haven’t felt a pressing need to read any more of her books, which is interesting….


    • Café Society February 21, 2019 / 4:31 pm

      Yes, Karen, even though one of the group has started the new book and spoke highly of what she had so far read I don’t feel an desire to get hold of a copy.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Helen February 21, 2019 / 9:14 pm

    I’ve read all three of Diane Setterfield’s books and her latest one, Once Upon a River, is my favourite. I wasn’t very impressed with Bellman and Black – looking back at my review to remind myself of it, I see that I also mentioned feeling that there were too many ideas not fully developed. I do remember being fascinated by the descriptions of the emporium and the Victorian mourning industry, though!


    • Café Society February 22, 2019 / 3:18 pm

      The person who had chosen Bellman and Black had just started Once Upon A River, Helen, and said that she thought it was a much more mature work. I might give it a go if the library buys a copy.


  3. FictionFan February 22, 2019 / 8:15 am

    This is the only one of her books I’ve read and I found it didn’t seem to fulfil its promise. I enjoyed her writing but I felt she got a bit lost in the minutiae, even though it was interesting, and didn’t quite manage to tell a satisfying story. I’ve been tempted by her new one though – I’ve seen so many glowing reviews of it…


    • Café Society February 22, 2019 / 3:19 pm

      Yes, FF, a friend has said she thinks it is a more mature work so I might try it if the library gets a copy. Just at the moment I don’t feel like spending money on it.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Annabel (AnnaBookBel) February 22, 2019 / 10:16 am

    Having not enjoyed the first, I don’t think I’ll carry on with this author – I have too many other books to read.


  5. Jane @ Beyond Eden Rock February 22, 2019 / 12:37 pm

    I loved ‘The Thirteenth Tale’ but was horribly disappointed with this book. The ideas were wonderful but I think your book club came to the right conclusions.


    • Café Society February 22, 2019 / 3:21 pm

      Will you be reading the new one, Jane do you think? The Bears asked me to inquire after Briar.


      • Jane @ Beyond Eden Rock February 22, 2019 / 3:34 pm

        I’ve read it and loved it. Briar is not as young as she was but she is well and sends greetings to The Bears.


  6. Jenny @ Reading the End February 25, 2019 / 11:53 pm

    >although we had all found it eminently readable, we none of us thought that it quite held together.

    This is a perfect summation of how I felt about The Thirteenth Tale. The trappings were excellent and should have been the perfect fit for me! There were many elements introduced that were bonkers, and I love a bonkers story! But overall it didn’t hold together the way I wanted it to.


    • Café Society February 26, 2019 / 11:30 am

      Exactly, Jenny. I should have loved everything about that book and yet I came away from it really unsatisfied. Having had the same experience twice now with Setterfield’s work, however well her new book is being reviewed I’m not really tempted by it.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s