The Scholar ~ Dervla McTiernan

Dervla McTiernan’s first novel, The Ruin, which introduced Galway based Gardaí sergeant, Cormac Reilly, was published last year to almost universal acclaim.  I very much enjoyed it on a first read, but was less certain a second time round.  I thought McTiernan started too many hares and that as a result the central narrative line got lost. I was also concerned about the number of members of the Galway force who were at best incompetent, at worst corrupt.  I have friends living in Galway and I feared for their safety.  I came to The Scholar, the second in the series, therefore, with a certain amount of trepidation.  Fortunately, this novel is more tightly plotted and, while there are still one or two members of the force who clearly have issues, I suspect that is true of any group of police and this time round there is, thank goodness, a sense that as a whole they do actually want to see justice done.

Cormac Reilly has transferred from Dublin to Galway to be with his partner, Emma Sweeney, who has secured a five year funded position at a medical research lab.  The two met after Emma was charged with a murder from which she was later exonerated and the experience, unsurprisingly, has left scars on both of them.  When, therefore, Emma rings Cormac and tells him that she has found a dead body in the University car park he is concerned not only for her well-being but also that she may be seen as a suspect in what turns out to be a particularly vicious, and clearly deliberate, hit and run.  When it becomes apparent that the victim has links to the facility in which Emma works Reilly’s involvement in the case becomes questionable however, he is determined to hang on to the investigation not only to ensure that Emma is not unduly pressured but also because this is the first real test of his ability in his new posting.

At the heart of the case are two seriously dysfunctional families.  Carline Darcy is the granddaughter of a man who has made billions through the development of medical advances. John Darcy is a seriously nasty piece of work, who has no time for Carline despite the fact that she seems to crave his approval.  To that end she has enrolled on the Bio-Pharmaceutical Chemistry degree at the University and is seeking to prove by her work that she is worthy of a place in Darcy Pharmaceuticals.  Here she encounters and works alongside Della Lambert, the eldest daughter of a family struggling to make ends meet after the financial crash causes her father to lose his business.  On the face of it, the two girls have nothing in common, but there is one thing that Della can apparently offer Carline: a way to gain her grandfather’s approval.

To anyone who has worked in the University sector, Carline’s plan is obviously flawed,  but at eighteen you think you can order the world to run in line with your scenario.  Sooner rather than later her scheme would have come crashing down around both girls heads. However, there is one member of Darcy Pharmaceutical who can’t afford to wait for that to happen and, with Emma Sweeney on hand to be offered up as the obvious suspect, that individual decides to take deadly action.

I think this is definitely a more tightly written book than The Ruin and McTiernan has given greater definition to more of her characters, especially Emma, Cormac’s fellow sergeant, Carrie O’Halloran, and Garda Peter Fisher, who is clearly ripe either for promotion for using his own initiative or dismissal on the grounds of overstepping the mark. While she isn’t yet rivalling Claire McGowan or Tana French in respect of Irish crime writing, I will certainly be coming back for more.


9 thoughts on “The Scholar ~ Dervla McTiernan

  1. Jane @ Beyond Eden Rock March 6, 2019 / 9:48 am

    I liked ‘The Ruin’ but I completely agree with your third sentence, and I am very pleased to know that you think this book was more tightly written, because I did see a lot of promise in that first book.


  2. Café Society March 6, 2019 / 10:41 am

    When you look back at the early efforts of any established and lauded crime writer you can always find flaws, don’t you think, Jane? The progress that McTiernan has made between these two books suggests to me that she will go on to rank among the best.


  3. Lisa March 6, 2019 / 12:31 pm

    For some reason the Irish crime stories aren’t as easily available in the US – at least in my part of it. We’re still well-stocked with Scandinavian crime, so maybe the Irish stories will “catch on” at some point.


    • Café Society March 6, 2019 / 5:57 pm

      I hope so, Lisa, because there are some excellent writers coming out of Ireland. As well as the ones I mentioned you might also want to look out for Brian McGilloway who, like Claire McGowan, is very interested in what it means to be trying to police the border between the two states.


  4. Cathy746books March 6, 2019 / 6:16 pm

    Sounds like a good one – I’ve not read her yet so must check her out.


    • Café Society March 6, 2019 / 6:49 pm

      If you’ve the time, Cathy, go back and read The Ruin First; it will set the overall scene and characters for you.


  5. FictionFan March 6, 2019 / 11:52 pm

    Debut novels are often a bit messy, so it’s good to hear she’s improved so much in her second. This sounds great – my wishlist is getting more out of control with every review I read at the moment… 😉


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s